The Curse of Stigmatized Homes

On the face of it, it looks like the dream home for any successful, middle-class couple – four bedrooms, incredibly spacious with new carpets and hardwood flooring upstairs. Moreover, it’s situated in a great part of Poway district in California, much sought after location with several great schools nearby. All this could be yours for just $399,000. So why won’t it sell?


The stigmatized home at Olive Grove Place, Poway, has been listed for months. Courtesy

Because this home is also home to a sinister secret – it’s what’s known in the industry as a “stigmatized property”, a home where something terrible occurred.

According to the National Association of Realtors, a stigmatized property is one where either a real or rumored event took place which, while not physically affecting the property, has had an adverse impact on its desirability.

The owners of the seemingly-perfect property described above, a Mr. and Mrs. Cunningham were brutally murdered by one of their neighbors in Easter 2010, before their killer was himself gunned down by police inside the property.


Heaven's Gate cult mansion, courtesy of

This is just one of many otherwise desirable properties in the California area that cannot shake off that stigma. Another famous example is a mansion in Rancho Santa Fe. Previously home to the Heaven’s Gate cult, it was the scene of a mass suicide involving 39 of its members in 1999. After years on the market, the mansion was finally sold for far less than its value, before being promptly torn down and replaced with an entirely new property.

The owner of the realtors responsible for selling the Poway home, Jason Ramsey of Home Realty USA, has already shown numerous people around the property, but virtually all of them ruled out living there once they found out what transpired. The problem they face is a legal (as well as moral) responsibility to disclose what happened at the property.


Homes that have been the scene of gruesome crimes often sell at rock bottom prices. Image courtesy

When asked, the president of the San Diego Association of Realtors, Bob Kevane, admitted that he had never managed to sell a property which was the scene of a murder. While numerous homes involving deaths by natural causes are sold on, it seems that many of us simply cannot bear the prospect of living somewhere with such a ghoulish past.

For anyone brave enough however, there are more than a few bargains to be had out there.


Mike Wheatley

Mike Wheatley is the senior editor at Realty Biz News. Got a real estate related news article you wish to share, contact Mike at

Recent Posts

Which Carpet Cleaning Tool Is The Best?

Do you have carpets in your home? Wait, where are you going. Don’t go anywhere…

5 hours ago

Sales of new homes drop by double-digits

New home buyers are being deterred by higher prices, and that became readily apparent in…

7 hours ago

Which fire protection equipment are the best for a commercial building?

Owners of commercial buildings must provide a safe working environment to their employees. Based on…

7 hours ago

15 Ways Real Estate Agents Can Increase Their Organic Traffic

"Cultivate visibility because attention is currency," said author Chris Brogan. This couldn't be more true when…

8 hours ago

ARMs offer tempting mortgage savings, but there’s a risk

A new study from Redfin shows that homebuyers could save an average of $260 per…

1 day ago

AgentStory Launches, Providing Consumers Unprecedented Transparency on Real Estate Agent Performance

A Miami-based real estate technology startup is providing new transparency in the process of selecting…

2 days ago