One can easily argue, and strongly, that price per square foot has no value in ascertaining value at all. Many variables inherent in deriving price per square foot are insignificant and that renders conclusions based upon them all but worthless. There are of course exceptions; new tract construction, tract condominiums and on occasion newer commercial properties. This article considers existing homes as it is frequently applied broadly and quite inaccurately.
In most cases, price per square foot is derived by dividing sale price by total living area. Simple math for a seemingly simple conclusion, but consider just a few of the more obvious and not so obvious variables (in no order):
Sale price. What were the circumstances of the sale? Distressed? Arm’s length? Motivated seller or one not needing to sell? Closing costs? Were they included or deducted as a concession?
Buyer. Is this a measured purchase or one by a relo in with a weekend to buy? Were concessions like closing costs, repairs, personal property added to the price? Were concessions made for cash?
Buyer and seller. Are they educated about the process? Working with competent agents? Savvy with regard to financing and how that may impact the price?
Square Footage. What is the source of the living area? Is it accurate? Was there a finished basement included in the figure? Does the living area meet FNMA guidelines? Who measured it?
Condition and Updating. What was the condition of the home? Was it updated? What level of maintenance is there?
Quality. Is this a custom home, tract home, modular or even mobile? What level are the construction and finishing materials? What about complexity of design; ranch vs custom? Ceiling height? Energy features? Granite or Formica? Brick or frame?
Features. Is there a basement? Finished? How is it finished? Deck? Pool? Garage or carport? Home theater?
Site. Is the site functional? Improved with hardscapes? Any adverse external influences? Public utilities? Overall size and terrain? Features and appeal?
Market Trends. What is going on in the micro market? What is the competing market area? Is it clearly defined?
Old and New. Are new homes being considered with older existing? Are builders providing incentives? Were the lots purchased at a discount? Is it a mixed community of older and new homes? Does that impact appeal and ultimately price?
Economic. What is the economic status of the micro and macro market? Labor costs? Union or non-union? Illegal workers paid in cash? Fluctuating material costs? Unfinished residential and commercial projects?
There are obviously more, these are just the ones that come to mind. The most significant one however is the SUBJECTIVITY around the entire process; there are no uniform guidelines because there simply cannot be. It is difficult enough to find a group of appraisers to agree when evaluating a single home, never mind tossing real estate agents into the mix. Experience, opinions, data sources….all play a role when evaluating a single property, the idea that this can be done for an area with the variables inherent in real estate simply doesn’t hold up.
Resist the urge to selectively apply the data frequently pushed by national sources; Case-Shiller, Zestimates and similar macro analysis is good media fodder, however it is all but worthless at the micro market level. Understand the limitations when trying to estimate the market value of a property; no two parcels are the same and the variables are significant. The single most reliable indicator of market value is the market itself; and that is a constantly moving target.
Hank Miller is a full time Associate Broker and Certified Appraiser in Atlanta. He is known as much for his attention to detail as he is for his candor. Visit www.hankmillerteam.com for all things real estate.
What’s In It For Me? Leads, Sales and Appointments
Please select a valid form
The internet has revolutionized how properties are rented, bought, & sold. Don’t get left behind! Join Digital Marketer Zach Parker as Realty Biz News is now offering digital marketing training for real estate professionals so you can build your digital brand and generate more leads online!
Appointments
Open house appointments, virtual tours, Zoom or mobile meetings for your potential buyers
Exclusive Content
Access to exclusive content covering the latest trends in real estate digital marketing
Digital Training
Bi-weekly newsletter providing in-depth digital marketing training for real estate pros
Step by Step Articles
Step-by-step articles teach you how to build digital marketing campaigns that get solid leads
Expert Insights
Webinar training from experts in the field of real estate digital marketing
SEO
Learn how to optimize your MLS website through SEO in month
Subscribe Now and unlock all the tools you need to increase your sales, generate leads and understand real estate digital marketing.